Lawyers are trained to see each matter as unique. A new client walks in with a new set of facts, a new opponent and a new question of law, and we treat the work that follows as bespoke. There is some truth in that. No two disputes are the same, and the facts matter.
But after several years watching litigation from different seats, I have come to think that this framing hides something. The facts change. The law changes. The method does not.
The view from different seats
My first exposure to litigation was as a summer law student at a boutique firm and then at a top national law firm in Canada in 2018 and 2019. I then clerked as a judicial assistant at the Court of Appeal for Saskatchewan, which gave me the view from the other side. I spent the next four years as a litigation solicitor in London, before moving into a legal engineering role, where I now build out the workflows I used to run by hand.
Each of those seats taught me something different. But whether as a law clerk or as a lawyer, once you read other lawyers' work at volume, you start to see what separates good legal work from the rest. It is thoroughness and attention to detail, yes. But underneath that, the best work always has structure and method. The lawyers behind it have developed their own way of doing things, and they follow it every time.
Behind high-quality legal work there is always a system, even if no one has written it down.
Matters, not systems
Take a fact chronology. On any given matter it feels like a piece of original work. You are reading documents you have never seen, about people you have never met, and building a story from scratch.
Yet the steps are the same on every matter. You gather the documents. You pull out each dated event and tie it to its source. You reconcile the accounts that conflict. You flag what goes to the issues in dispute. The content is new each time, but the discipline is not.
The same is true of a witness statement, a disclosure review, or a letter before action. Litigators and in-house counsel handling disputes run these processes over and over. We just don't describe them that way, because the profession taught us to think in matters rather than systems.
Most of us did not learn these methods from a manual either. We picked them up over years, from seniors marking up our drafts and from seeing what worked and what didn't. The method is real, but it often lives in people's heads.
Why this matters for AI
This is where AI comes in, and where I think a lot of lawyers start in the wrong place.
The instinct is to treat AI as a clever assistant you hand a task to, one prompt at a time. That works up to a point. But it treats every task as a one-off, which is the same matters-not-systems habit in a new form.
The lawyers who get the most out of AI start somewhere else. They look at their work and ask which parts follow the same rhythm every time. Then they map those steps out, decide where AI can automate them or speed them up, and build the workflow around that.
Doing this forces you to write down the method that was sitting in your head. In my experience that is where much of the value lies. Once the method is explicit, you can improve it, share it with a team, and hand the repeatable parts to AI. A method that only exists in a senior lawyer's head, on the other hand, can't be delegated to anyone.
I saw this first-hand when I built a fact chronology workflow for litigation matters. The hard part was not getting AI to produce a list of dates. It was getting it to follow the same discipline a good litigator would. That meant focusing on the facts that matter to the issues, tying every entry back to its source, and explaining any conflict it found. Where the claimant and the defendant take different views of the same event, the workflow flags it rather than quietly picking a side. None of that came from a clever prompt. It came from writing down the method first.
The judgement objection
The pushback I hear most often is that legal work turns on judgement, and judgement can't be systematised.
I agree with the premise. Judgement is the part of the job that clients pay for. As lawyers, we also have professional duties to act independently and to exercise our own judgement. No workflow replaces that. But systems thinking is not about systematising judgement. It is about systematising the discipline and the steps that surround it.
When the chronology is built in a consistent way, you spend your time deciding what it means rather than assembling it. When a first draft follows a structure you trust, you spend your time on the argument rather than the formatting. The system doesn't take judgement away from the lawyer. It gives the lawyer more time to use it.
Where to start
If you want to try this, pick one task you do often and write down every step you take, in order, as if you were training a trainee. Then look at the list and ask which steps need you and which only need doing.
The ones that only need doing are your starting point. Write these down and work with AI to build a workflow around them.
We will always need lawyers who can read a case and know what matters. The difference now is that we can stop spending our best hours on the parts that were never bespoke to begin with.